Anna Maria Island, a charming slice of paradise on Florida’s Gulf Coast, is not only known for its pristine beaches and quaint boutiques but also for its vibrant culinary scene. Whether you’re a food enthusiast or a casual traveller, the island offers a variety of delectable dishes that are sure to delight your taste buds. From fresh seafood caught daily to delightful desserts, here’s a guide to some of the best food to try in Anna Maria Island.
The Grouper Sandwich is perhaps the most iconic dish on Anna Maria Island. The island’s close proximity to the Gulf of Mexico means that the grouper is always fresh, making for a sandwich that’s bursting with flavour. Whether you prefer it blackened, grilled, or fried, the Grouper Sandwich is a must-try. Many local restaurants, such as the famous Sandbar Restaurant, serve this dish with a side of crispy fries or coleslaw, providing the perfect beachside meal.
If you’re visiting between October and May, don’t miss out on the stone crab claws, a true Floridian delicacy. These sweet, tender claws are often served chilled with a side of mustard sauce. The Waterfront Restaurant and Bar is a great place to enjoy this seasonal treat while taking in the stunning views of Tampa Bay. The combination of fresh, succulent crab meat and the tangy sauce makes for a dining experience that captures the essence of the island.
No visit to Anna Maria Island is complete without indulging in a slice of Key Lime Pie. This dessert, made with tart key lime juice, sweetened condensed milk, and a graham cracker crust, strikes the perfect balance between sweet and tangy. Many local bakeries and restaurants, like the Rod and Reel Pier, serve up their own versions of this classic Floridian dessert. Some places even offer frozen variations, perfect for cooling down on a hot day.
For a more casual dining option, Mahi-Mahi Tacos are a fantastic choice. The mild, flaky fish pairs wonderfully with fresh toppings like avocado, cilantro, and lime. Often served on soft corn tortillas, these tacos are a flavorful, light option that still satisfies. Poppo’s Taqueria, a popular spot on the island, offers a build-your-own taco experience, allowing you to customize your meal to your liking.
Shrimp and Grits is a Southern classic that has found a home on Anna Maria Island. This dish typically features plump, juicy shrimp sautéed with garlic, onions, and bell peppers, all served over a bed of creamy, cheesy grits. The flavours meld together beautifully, creating a comforting, satisfying dish. The Blue Marlin Grill is known for its upscale take on this traditional favourite, offering a version that’s rich and full of flavour.
For breakfast or brunch, Ginny’s & Jane E’s Café and Coastal Store is the place to be. This quirky café, located in a historic building, is famous for its massive cinnamon rolls, but it also serves up an array of breakfast favourites, from hearty omelettes to avocado toast. The eclectic décor and laid-back atmosphere make it a popular spot for both locals and visitors. Pair your meal with a freshly brewed coffee or a mimosa for the perfect start to your day.
After a day of exploring Anna Maria Island, treat yourself to some island-style ice cream. Small, locally-owned shops like Two Scoops Ice Cream offer a variety of flavours, from traditional vanilla and chocolate to more adventurous options like key lime or coconut. The creamy, refreshing treat is the perfect way to cool down after a day in the Florida sun.
Anna Maria Island offers a rich tapestry of culinary delights that reflect both its coastal location and its Southern roots. From fresh seafood to sweet desserts, every meal is an opportunity to savour the flavours of this beautiful island. So, the next time you find yourself in Anna Maria Island, be sure to indulge in these must-try dishes that showcase the best of what this tropical paradise has to offer.
What’s top of your list of food to try in Anna Maria Island? With so much tasty fare on offer, you’ll need to make sure to rest your head somewhere comfortable and beautiful. Check out our luxury villas in Anna Maria Island and the full portfolio of homes in Florida. Get in touch with our concierge service who are happy to help advise and book all manner of fabulous extra services!
If you're looking for the perfect luxury villa to rent for your big day, you've… Read More
Family holidays are always special – you get to spend quality time together (a rarity… Read More
Guest post by Dakota Murphey When you think of a perfect winter stay, cosy chalets with… Read More
It’s no secret that France is always a hit holiday destination for the whole family.… Read More
There’s more to Menorca than its historic twin cities and mysterious Neolithic monuments. Its 200km-long… Read More
Historical architecture, sandy beaches, plentiful national parks and homegrown wine – it’s not hard to… Read More